| Rank Order | Name of President | Years of Service |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | William A. Caldwell | 1894 - 1896 |
| 2 | William R. King | 1896 - 1899 |
| 3 | Arthur G. Evans | 1899 - 1908 |
| (interim) | Levi H. Beeler | 1908 - 1909 |
| 4 | Seth Gordon | 1909 - 1911 |
| 5 | Fred Hawley | 1911 - 1915 |
| (interim) | Ralph Lamb | 1915 - 1916 |
| 6 | Charles Evans | 1916 - 1917 |
| (interim) | James McMurty | 1917 - 1918 |
| 7 | Arthur Odell | 1918 - 1920 |
| 8 | James Gordon | 1920 - 1924 |
| (interim) | Franklin Dill | 1924 - 1927 |
| 9 | John Finlayson | 1927 - 1934 |
| 10 | Ralph Langenheim | 1934 - 1935 |
| 11 | Clarence Pontius | 1935 - 1958 |
| 12 | Ben G. Henneke | 1958 - 1967 |
| 13 | Eugene Swearingen | 1967 - 1968 |
| 14 | J. Paschal Twyman | 1968 - 1989 |
| (interim) | John Dowgray | 1977 |
| (interim) | Michael Davis | 1989 - 1990 |
| 15 | Robert Donaldson | 1990 - 1996 |
| 16 | Robert Lawless | 1996 - 2004 |
| 17 | Steadman Upham | 2004 - 2012 |
| 18 | Geoffrey Orsak | 2012 |
| 19 | Steadman Upham | 2012 - 2016 |
| 20 | Gerard P. Clancy | 2016 - 2020 |
| (interim) | Janet K. Levit | 2020 - 2021 |
| 21 | Brad Carson | 2021 - |